Principles of living a godly life [60] – The condemnation of self-forfeiture and completion of the law [2]

 ‘For the powerless incapable law, within which it is weak and feeble by means of the flesh, God, having sent His Son within resemblance of self-forfeiting flesh, and concerning no share and self-forfeiture, has condemned loss and self-forfeiture within the flesh, 4 in order that the judicial approval and rightwise acts of the Law are being made full and complete within us – the not walking around down from flesh, but down from breath’, [pneuma], (Romans 8 v 3, 4).

The outline that I presented in the previous post means that I dismiss the legalist’s suggestion that I am negating the Law or advocating opposition to divine Law so as to promote an excessively permissive Christian lifestyle. I am not saying that because Christians are now on the road to honour and praise that it therefore does not matter how they behave. Paul agrees. ‘Not at all’ says the Apostle, ‘just the opposite’. Rather, what divine Law approves of is beginning and continuing to be made full and complete within us. This is not something that has happened and been completed sometime in the past, rather it is a process that started in the past, when Christians were effectively brought forth and were indwelt by the set-apart Breath, and this process is continuing now and into the future. 

Some legalists step in once again. (They are a persistent and insistent bunch of people). Some of them propose that Paul is referring to something that was fully completed sometime in the past, because they then go on to emphasise a distinction between ‘Justification’ and ‘’Sanctification’. They say, ‘Yes, Christians have indeed been fully rescued and delivered in the Messiah. Their deliverance was fully accomplished and secured by the Messiah by means of his death and resurrection, and it was applied to individual Christians in the past when they were effectively brought forth or born again’. Their inference is that Christians have fully met the requirements of the Law in terms of their ultimate acquittal thanks to the work of Jesus. Christians stand as those who are declared judicially approved by means of the Messiah. They stand justified – judicially approved and rightwise in front of God by means of Jesus. Legalists say that in this sense their deliverance is sure and certain. But then they go on to say, ‘Now that a Christian has been brought forth or ‘born again’, they are called and exhorted to live a godly life in practice, day-by-day’. So far, so good, I fully agree. Like many of their fellow Christians, they refer to this ongoing godly service and process of increasing maturity in godliness as ‘sanctification’ – the process of change in which the Christian is increasingly set apart from worldliness. I refer to it as maintaining godliness and being rightwise in practice day-by-day. But then the legalist says, ‘This is where we turn to divine law! Not for justification, but for sanctification - for living a godly life day-by-day. Are you, as a Christian, stealing? What does Covenant law say? It says You will not steal’. That is the legalist’s approach.

But that is not what Paul is saying at all. Christians are not justified or judicially approved and made rightwise by entrusting Jesus only to then be sanctified or changed into the image of the Messiah day-by-day by turning to labouring and making the effort to obey the written codes of the (moral aspects of) divine law. Rather, the Apostle says that what the Messiah has done is in order that the ‘approval of the Law be made full and complete within us’. The fullness, completion or end result of divine law is now beginning to happen ‘within us’, rather than by our attempts to observe external written codes. If we are in any doubt as to what Paul means, he goes on to tell us plainly. First, this is certainly not something that is happening within the worldly arrangement, it is not arising within human nature in general. Second, it is not happening by attempts to conform to external written codes of law. Rather, it is happening only within Christians – ‘the not walking around down from flesh, but down from breath’.

So now we have this – 

Life within Jesus the Messiah down from Breath

Working in opposition to

Self-forfeiture, loss, and the death, down from flesh

Therefore, Christians who are living a godly life moment-by-moment are –

Walking around down from breath

Principles of living a set apart, godly life [59] – The condemnation of self-forfeiture and completion of the law [1]

 ‘For the powerless incapable law, within which it is weak and feeble by means of the flesh, God, having sent His Son within resemblance of self-forfeiting flesh, and concerning no share and self-forfeiture, has condemned loss and self-forfeiture within the flesh, 4 in order that the judicial approval of the Law is being made full and complete within us – the not walking around down from flesh, but down from breath’, [pneuma], (Romans 8 v 3, 4). 

Paul does not direct Christians to try to observe the written codes of Sinai Covenant law such as the Ten Commandments in the way legalists would have Christians do. Instead he points Christians to God’s free gift of His only-begotten Son. The free gift of the Son is the means of judicial approval. But legalists begin to qualify what Paul is saying. ‘Aha!’ they say. ‘When Paul talks about law, and when he talks about Christians dying away from law, (Romans 7 v 4), and being set free from the written code of Covenant law, (Romans 7 v 6), he means Ceremonial Law’. This is because legalists divide Covenant law into two aspects - Ceremonial Law and Moral Law - and they then propose that Christians are delivered from Ceremonial Law, but that they are still under Moral Law. Why? Because Jesus has fulfilled the Ceremonial law, but he has not come to abolish Moral law. On this basis they turn Christians once again to the written codes of law such as the Ten Commandments, so as to encourage them to keep the Sabbath, or to tithe, or such like. 

But that is not what Paul is saying. Nowhere does Paul make that kind of distinction concerning Covenant law, and he certainly does not do so here in his letter to the Romans. Neither was it customary for Jews – to whom Sinai Covenant law was given – to understand Covenant law in this way. They saw Covenant law as a whole, as a unified entity, an integrated system. So I dismiss this legalist proposal.

Paul does not direct Christians to Covenant law but instead, as we see in verse 3, he does the opposite. He points out the weakness of Covenant law and directs Christians to the Messiah instead. Why? Because Christians retain their flesh with its inherent principle of self-forfeiture, but Jesus decisively judges down against loss and self-forfeiture within our flesh, by condemning it within the likeness of sinful flesh as God’s sacrificial Lamb without spot or blemish. Self-forfeiture and loss is effectively condemned and sent away for those entrusting the Messiah by means of the Messiah’s acceptable substitutionary atoning sacrifice as the spotless Lamb of God. Jesus paid the purchase price required to buy back those whom God has selected – that price being the spilt life-blood and physical death of the Messiah within the likeness of sinful flesh. 

Why is self-forfeiture and loss condemned and paid for by the Messiah on behalf of those brought forth by God? Paul tells us in verse 4 – ‘in order that the judicial approval of the Law is being made full and complete within us’. For Christians, the judicial approval of the law is now being made full and complete – not by Christians trying to observe external written codes, but the law is being made full and complete within them. How is this happening? What is the fundamental principle or dynamic process? He goes on to tell us. 

Self-forfeiture and loss is condemned by the Messiah in order that the judicial approval, the fundamental principle of the law – the enactment of law, the practical obedience which the law calls for, the goal of the law - is being made full and complete in us, or ‘realised in us’. He defines ‘us’ as ‘the not walking around down from the flesh, but down from breath’.  In other words, Christians who are conducting their daily lives within the movement and direction of the Breath of Life in the Messiah that is present in their deep inner core. 

The purpose of the law is being made full and complete in Christians who are walking around moment-by-moment within the unction of the set-apart Breath residing in their heart

The self-forfeiting impulses of the Christian’s flesh still remain active as the verses that follow distinctly show, but the opposing Breath within Christians has broken their tied enslavement to these impulses. In this way, Christians have been brought forth as a new orderly form, their old form or self has passed away, impaled on the execution post of the cross.

However, it does not follow that any Christians will actually completely avoid all wayward behaviour, nor that they are accepted on the basis of their own actions. This would contradict other Scripture texts (James 2 v 10; I John 1 v 8). Paul confessed that he was not already perfect or fully complete himself, (Philippians 3 v 12). But fullness and completion by means of the atoning sacrifice of the Messiah and the set-apart Breath dwelling within them, is presented as the goal and the means of those whom God has selected (Matthew 5 v 48). By actual practical, progressive growth and maturity Christians are to show that their union with the Messiah is real. The Breath within them gives a new dynamic, direction and tone to their character and their life, working in opposition to the impulses that still remain active within the fabric of their fleshly constitution.

Principles of living a set apart, godly life [58] – Two fundamental principles

 ‘…Under these circumstances, no judicial condemnation within Jesus the Messiah at this present time 2 because the fundamental principle of the Breath, [Pneuma], the Life within Jesus the Messiah, has set you free away from the fundamental principle of self-forfeiture, loss and the death. For the powerless incapable law, within which it is weak and feeble by means of the flesh, God, having sent His Son within resemblance of self-forfeiting flesh, and concerning self-forfeiture and loss, has condemned self-forfeiture and loss within the flesh’, (Romans 8 v 1 - 3).

Paul mentions two opposing fundamental dynamic principles of movement within Christians – 

Life within Jesus the Messiah

And

Self-forfeiture, loss, and the death

The principle, inclination and direction of movement towards self-forfeiture, loss and death is inherent within the fabric of our fleshly constitution and works in opposition to God. As a Christian, ‘I’ closely identify with delight in the honourable, praiseworthy law of God, but this principle within my fleshly constitution leads me to self-forfeiting behaviours that ‘I’ do not intend. 

But Christians are brought forth as part of the free gift of God by means of the Messiah and they possess the set-apart Breath that is moving on the basis of the fundamental principle of Life within the Messiah. The consequence is that ‘the Breath, [Pneuma], has set them free away from the fundamental principle of self-forfeiture, loss and the death’. Christians possess a direction of movement, a current, deep within their inner core that ‘outsiders’ or ‘unbelievers’ do not possess. 

How does this relate to the written codes of Covenant law? ‘For the powerless incapable law, within which it is weak and feeble by means of the flesh, God, having sent His Son within resemblance of self-forfeiting flesh, and concerning self-forfeiture and loss, has condemned self-forfeiture and loss within the flesh’, (Romans 8 v 3). Paul has been looking at the objections of those seeking divine approval by means of seeking to obey the injunctions of divine law since chapter 7 v 1. He has not forgotten that Covenant law has been an aspect of his discussion of divine approval, and he returns to divine law in verse 3, in the light of all that he has been saying, particularly since chapter 7.

 

So where does Paul direct Christians when it comes to perpetual Life with a capital ‘L’ - to sensitivity and responsiveness to God and His Messiah? Where do Christians look to obtain Life-energy that opposes the impetus of self-forfeiture, loss and death inherent in their flesh, in their day-to-day existence? ‘Aha!’ say Christian legalists. ‘We look to divine law! We look to the written codes of Mosaic Law – of Sinai Covenant Law, such as the Ten Commandments - to spur us on towards a clean, godly life.’ But that is not what Paul says here, or anywhere else. Given what he has been saying, Paul initially points Christians to the free gift of by means of Jesus the Messiah.

How is divine approval attained and maintained in daily life? How is self-forfeiture dealt with? Not by turning to try to walk in obedience to the written codes of divine law. Why don’t Christians turn to Covenant law if they agree with delight in divine law that is good, honourable and praiseworthy? Christians don’t turn to divine law because it is weak, feeble, powerless and incapable. The reason for this weakness of the law is the Christian’s earthy, sensuous, fleshly constitution with its inherent principle of self-forfeiture, loss and death that moves in opposition to God. 

Divine approval is attained like this - God loves the world in this way – He sent His only-begotten Son in the likeness of flesh, such that His Messiah condemns self-forfeiture and loss within the flesh. Paul does not direct Christians to divine law because our fleshly constitution makes the law weak and ineffective. Instead, he directs Christians to the good news of the free gift of God, Jesus the Messiah. Why? He will explain in the next verse.  

Principles of living a set apart, godly life [57] – No condemnation within Jesus [3]

 ‘What will deliver me from this death-body? Rejoice! The free kindness and favour of God by means of Jesus the Messiah our Lord! So then indeed, I am willingly serving God’s law with the mind, but [my] flesh, [is enslaved to] fundamental principles of self-forfeiture and loss. Under these circumstances, no judicial condemnation within Jesus the Messiah at this present time 2 because the fundamental principle of the Breath, [Pneuma], the Life within Jesus the Messiah, has set you free away from the fundamental principle of the self-forfeiture, loss and the death’, (Romans 7 v 25 – 8 v 1, 2). 

This is how Paul is logically reasoning as we come to the beginning of chapter 8. He has been dealing with some anticipated objections to the way of divine approval since the beginning of chapter 6, especially in relation to the Christian’s freedom away from the written codes of divine Law. He is now beginning to bring together his conclusion about the wider theme of divine approval, especially in relation to Covenant law. He has introduced ‘the free kindness and favour of God by means of Jesus the Messiah our Lord’, and has made the general statement that ‘Under these circumstances, no judicial condemnation within Jesus the Messiah at this present time’, (verse 1). 

Even though as a Christian ‘I am willingly serving God’s law with the mind, but [my] flesh [is enslaved to] fundamental principles of self-forfeiture and loss’, nevertheless, at this present moment, because of the ‘the free kindness and favour of God by means of Jesus the Messiah our Lord…Under these circumstances, [there is] no judicial condemnation within Jesus the Messiah at this present time’. Note that Paul is not referring to something that will happen in the future. He is not saying that there will be no condemnation at some time in the future, at the Great Assizes. He is saying that there is no condemnation now, at this present time. 

Paul tells us why is there no condemnation in the next verse. ‘Because the fundamental principle of the Breath, [Pneuma], the Life within Jesus the Messiah, has set you free away from the fundamental principle of self-forfeiture, loss and the death’, (Romans 8 v 2). Paul returns to the theme of ‘breath’ that he mentioned earlier in Romans 7 v 14. This time the Greek word has a capital letter indicating the Breath of God set-apart from the world. In connection with set-apart Breath he also introduces the concept of ‘the fundamental principle of the Breath, [Pneuma], the Life within Jesus the Messiah’, which he places in opposition to ‘the fundamental principle of the self-forfeiture, loss and the death’. In this verse he also moves the focus away from himself and to the Hebrew Christians. Having explained the situation using himself as an illustration, he now applies the themes he has introduced to these Jewish Christians and says ‘Life within Jesus the Messiah, has set you free away from the fundamental principle of self-forfeiture’.

So what is Paul describing? He says that ‘under these circumstances’ of ‘the free kindness and favour of God by means of Jesus the Messiah our Lord’ there is no judicial condemnation within the Messiah at this present time because of a ‘fundamental principle’. Paul uses the word ‘nomos’, meaning ‘law’ and this is very often how the verse is translated – ‘the law of the Spirit of the life in Jesus’. This Greek word can refer to ‘the written codes of Covenant Law’, or to ‘law’ as a general principle, or to both simultaneously. The particular sense is determined by the context. 

Because Paul is referring to the set-apart Breath I propose that Paul intends the sense of a ‘fundamental principle’, a basic truth about the movement of set-apart Breath, an authoritative regulation and guide of the direction of movement of set-apart Breath. What is the fundamental principle of set-apart Breath? It is ‘Life within Jesus the Messiah’. This movement of set-apart Breath, the principle of ‘Life within Jesus the Messiah’ has ‘set you free’. By ‘you’ Paul means Christians, especially Hebrew Christians who ‘know the law’. What are Christians set free away from? They are set free away from the ‘fundamental principle of self-forfeiture, loss and the death’. Once again, by the word ‘law’ Paul means a ‘fundamental principle’. As Paul has said earlier, ‘the extended free gift of God [is] perpetual Life within our Lord Jesus, the Messiah’, (Romans 6 v 20 – 23). This principle of the set-apart Breath - Life within the Messiah - has set Christians free from ‘the fundamental principle of self-forfeiture and loss’ that is inherent within their fleshly constitution, and ‘the death’. As part of the free gift of God by means of the Messiah, Christians possess the set-apart Breath in their deep inner core. The current of set-apart Breath, moving on the principle of Life within the Messiah, has liberated Christians away from the fundamental principle of the self-forfeiture, loss and the death that is inherent in their flesh. 

This liberation has been completed in the past. But make no mistake – I am not saying that Christians are therefore perfectly free from fleshly impulses, or that their battle against their fleshly impulses is easy. Nor am I saying that Christians are free to do anything they want. 

Principles of living a godly life [56] – No condemnation within Jesus [2]

 Paul possessed a legal frame of mind. He constructed his arguments and conclusions carefully and logically, paying close attention to the meaning of words. Sometimes his reasoning is complex. For example, most of us compare and contrast two elements or facets of a problem but Paul has now introduced no less than six elements, all of which are interconnected in some way. 

These are the elements that he has introduced in this discussion -

1) His main theme from chapter 6 has been divine Law in relation to obtaining divine approval. His stance is that Christians are dying away from and set free from the written codes of Sinai Covenant law. Nevertheless, Christians closely identify with delight in good, clean and praiseworthy divine law. 

2) By means of Sinai Covenant law people come to know self-forfeiture and loss. But self-forfeiture uses the opportunity provided by divine law as a starting point to increase, such that we see that self-forfeiture is present in all of our thoughts, words, desires and so on. Thanks to the written codes of Covenant law we are no longer ignorant of self-forfeiture and loss. But we are deceived, because we thought that divine law led to life – ‘Do this and you will live’ - but instead it leads us to death. Knowing Covenant law leads to a greater knowledge and experiential awareness of the extent and magnitude of self-forfeiture, divine disapproval and loss, which we come to plainly see.

3) Divine law pertains to the realm of Breath - the unseen current and energy away from God, the Messiah and the heavenly realm. 

4) Christians exist as flesh, which has inherent energies, impulses and inclinations that are opposed to Breath. 

This places Christians in a battle -

Fleshly energies work to bring divinely disapproved-of speech and behaviour to completion. 

On being brought forth by God, ‘I’ [ego] am not intending to engage in such disapproved-of behaviour. But fleshly impulses take me captive.

5) How can I be delivered away from my flesh? By the free gift of God by means of Jesus the Messiah, our Lord.

6) Under these circumstances, no judicial condemnation within Jesus the Messiah at this present time.

If the Apostle had been a juggler, he wouldn’t have been throwing two or three balls in the air, but these six. No wonder Romans chapter 7 proves to be a difficult chapter to interpret and understand correctly. At the start of chapter 8, Paul is continuing with his discussion of the means of divine approval – ‘Under these circumstances, no judicial condemnation at this present time’