Principles of living a set apart, godly life [32] – Divine Law and the error of legalism [2]

 If Christians turn to the written codes of divine Law to try to attain godliness and maintain divine approval day-by-day, then they are putting their faith in their flesh, in the strength of their human constitution, and thus they are taking a step backwards. They are stepping away from their calling to a superior order of a royal priesthood. In the case of Jews they are turning back to the Sinai Covenant and Levitical order, or in the case of Gentiles they are imposing the old and inferior Sinai Covenant with its Levitical Law given through Moses to Jews, onto Gentile Christians. More than this, in turning to the written codes of Law in this way they are in danger of rejecting their Messiah. They are going back to a form of divine approval by their work and effort – to maintaining divine approval by means of their own energies, actions and behaviours. The author of the Letter to the Hebrews says this - ‘But the judicially approved of Me will be alive from out of persuasion to the point of obedience, [Faith]. He who cowers, withholds or shrinks back, My Breath [psyche] is not well-pleased within him, [Habakkuk 2 v 4]. 39 But we are not those cowering and shrinking back penetrating into being cut off, but persuaded to the point of obedience penetrating into possessing life-breath [psyche]’, (Hebrews 10 v 38, 39). 

Elsewhere we read, ‘….if the people were completely fulfilled and made complete through the Levitical priesthood – on the basis that it was ordained and sanctioned by Covenant Law – why is there still need for another priest to be raised up according to the rank of Melchizedek, not being spoken of according to the rank of Aaron? [who was a Levite] 12 Because the priesthood is being transferred from out of necessity, from out of compelling need, and a transformation of law is coming into being. 13 Because these things [about Jesus as high priest] are being said on the basis of another tribe [Judah] participating…’, (Hebrews 7 v 11 – 13). I spent some time in earlier posts talking about Christians being placed into a different priestly order. Christians do not attain divine approval by seeking to obey the written codes of Levitical Law. God has brought them forth within hearing and persuasion of the good news of the Messiah, placing them into a royal priesthood of the order of Melchizedek. Therefore they do not now continue their Christian life day-by-day by turning back to, or placing themselves under trying to keep the written statutes of Levitical Law. Neither are they now free in the sense of being lawless or anti-law. Instead, there is a transformation of law. Divine law is not abolished or dissolved. The superior priesthood into which they have been placed exists alongside the written codes of Sinai Covenant law. For Christians, the principles of divine law work and come to fruition in a different way. 

So what is the Apostolic instruction to Christians? Trust in Jesus and work to keep the written codes of Sinai Covenant Law? No, not at all. The Apostles never say this. Instead they say, ‘Therefore, in the manner you have received the Lord Jesus, Messiah, walk around within Him, firmly established and built up within Him, making the persuasion secure in the manner you were taught, super-abounding within thankfulness’, (Colossians 2 v 6).

Principles of living a set apart, godly life [31] – Divine Law and the error of legalism [1]

Some Christian leaders propose that now that Christians have attained deliverance away from divine condemnation by means of entrusting in Jesus, then in order to go on, live a godly life and attain the highest standards of godliness day-by-day, Christians should now turn to the written codes of divine Law. They should turn to the written codes of the Sinai Covenant, where we find the Ten Commandments for example, to spur them on to avoid sin and encourage holiness. 

Here is Paul’s response to such a suggestion. ‘I wonder and marvel that in this manner you are quickly changing sides and transferring away from your summons within the Messiah’s free gift, penetrating into a different kind 7 that is absolutely not another good message. If whether there are some who are disturbing you and wish to corrupt the good news of the Messiah. 8 But even if we or a messenger from out of heaven proclaim good news to you alongside that good news we announced to you, let him be accursed! 9 As we have said before, so even at this moment I say, ‘If anyone is announcing good news to you beside what you received, let him be accursed!’’, (Galatians 1 v 6 – 9). Then, after defending his reputation, authority and integrity and that of the Apostles and the gospel message, he repeats the gospel which says that Christians are delivered from condemnation by faith, not by observing the written codes of the Law. Then he says, ‘O unthinking Galatians! Who has begun and continues to fascinate you not to be having confidence and trust the truth - that eyes down Jesus the Messiah announced as crucified? 2 I merely desire to learn this from you, did you receive the Breath [Pneuma] by means of working energies of Law, or by hearing confident entrustment? 3 Are you so thoughtless? Breath [Pneuma] beginning to make complete, [but] now at this present time, flesh? 4 Did you have so much heavy emotion without purpose, if indeed also without purpose? 5 Therefore, the supply of the Breath [Pneuma] to you and active power within you - from out of actions of Law or from out of hearing entrustment?’ (Galatians 3 v 1 – 6). 

Paul does not hold back. He says that a core aspect of the gospel is being undermined. Once again he contrasts the written codes of the Law on one hand, with hearing and persuasion, and with the Breath of God and God’s Son on the other hand. He places these in opposition to each other. If Christians turn to the written codes of Law in their attempt to attain godliness day-by-day, they are entrusting in their own energies and efforts to maintain judicial approval. They are entrusting their own flesh and the energies inherent within their human constitution. This means that they are taking a step backwards. The written codes of divine law are working down settled anger, not godliness.

 

Principles of living a set apart, godly life [30] – Divine Law and Divine approval [2]

 Christians are rescued from God’s judicial condemnation by means of entrusting Jesus. God’s chosen deliverer, rather than by seeking to enact all of the written regulations of Sinai Covenant Law. As part of God’s free gift, Christians receive the Breath of God to indwell their deep inner core or ‘heart’ – the foundation of their thoughts, feelings and intentions. Paul places faith and Breath in contrast to working to put into practice the external written codes of the Sinai Covenant. 

So what happens then? What happens in the Christian’s day-to-day life? As a result of their enlightened perception away from the Breath of God, and their entrustment in the Messiah, Christians are exhorted to exercise illuminated self-control so as to live a godly life by walking around within the set-apart Breath of God. Nowhere do the Apostles instruct Christians to turn to and work to put into practice the external written codes of divine Law. But as we have seen, divine Law – with its emphasis on purity, cleanliness and being set apart from the worldly arrangement and its values – has not been abolished. Christians are not given a licence to engage in wayward speech and behaviour because they now trust Jesus. But the exhortation to, and purpose of, living a godly life places them in a battle, in warfare, because within their physical, fleshly constitution, raw energies and passions produce an impetus that leads to speech and behaviour that God disapproves of. No Christian is perfectly clean and pure in their speech and behaviour, despite their best intentions, or their most transcendent experiences. 

Given this purpose and summons to live a godly life and the opposition created by the energies within their physical, fleshly constitution, as well as by the values and behaviours of the world being displayed around them, where does this leave Christians? How are they to go about their daily lives successfully overcoming temptation? How are they to maintain the best standard of godliness that they possibly can? 

Different Christian leaders suggest different approaches, but the particular focus here is on divine Law. ‘Aha!’ say some Christian leaders. ‘Christians need to turn to the written codes of divine Law, like the Ten Commandments, to ‘spur’ them on or ‘goad’ them towards godly behaviour’. Are they neglecting Sunday worship? The Law says ‘Keep the Sabbath set apart’. Are they stealing? The Law says ‘You will not steal’ and so on. But I strongly disagree with this approach. I propose that this is not Apostolic teaching and that it falls into the error of ‘Christian legalism’. 

Principles of living a set apart, godly life [29] – Divine Law and Divine approval [1]

 Many of the Apostolic references to divine Law refer to divine approval, to being declared righteous or placed in a position of no condemnation from God. Many Protestant Christian commentators (though not all), agree that no one is declared righteous by means of them trying to obey or keep the written codes of divine Law. Paul states the position of Christians succinctly in his letter to the Christians in Galatia. ‘Therefore, as many as exist from out of works and actions of Law exist under a curse. Because it is written, ‘Cursed, everyone who is not remaining within everything written in the book of the Law, constructing them. 11 Because now it is clearly evident that no one is judicially approved in the presence of God within the sphere of divine Law, because ‘The judicially approved will live from out of faithful confident persuasion’. 12 But the Law is not from out of confident persuasion, on the contrary, the one constructing these things will live by them. 13 The Messiah buys us up completely from out of the curse of the Law, having become a curse on behalf of us, because it is written, ‘Everyone hanging on a tree is accursed’, 14 in order that Abraham’s blessing comes to the Gentiles within Jesus the Messiah, so that we receive the promise - the Breath [pneuma] - through entrusting to the point of obedience’, (Galatians 3 v 10 – 14a).

Covenant Law says, ‘Do this and you will live’. That is the arrangement for those under the Sinai Covenant - ‘we know that whatever the Law says, it speaks to those within the Law’, (Romans 3 v 19), to Jews. ‘The hearers of the Law are not judicially approved alongside God, but the doers of Law will be declared judicially approved’, (Romans 2 v 13). But no one successfully obeys or keeps all of the Law. Rather, ‘The judicially approved will live from out of faithful confident persuasion’,  (verse 11 above). 

Paul contrasts doing the written codes of the Law with ‘faith’ and the Breath. These are two different means of obtaining divine approval. But he says that no one successfully enacts the written codes of divine law, so that instead, divine approval comes from faith, from entrustment to the point of obedience. In these last days, the Messiah and his atoning death at Calvary has been revealed and it is Jesus who is the focus of this faith or persuasion. The fruit and evidence of this entrustment is that it is carried across from within – from ‘inside the cup’ into godly speech and behaviour as Christians co-work with the Breath of God. 

This is the situation according to Paul - ‘Therefore, in front of Him all flesh will absolutely not be judicially approved from out of energy and work of Law, because by means of Law is full knowledge of self forfeiture and no share or portion. 21 But now apart and separate from Law, God’s judicial approval is being made clear and apparent, testified and borne witness to by the Law and the Prophets - 22 judicial approval by means of entrustment, penetrating toward all those entrusting Jesus the Messiah’, (Romans 3 v 20 – 22b). Paul states a conclusion on this matter a little later. ‘Because if those from out of Law are allotted heirs, [then] persuasion to the point of obedience is made void, is nullified, and the announced promise rendered entirely idle. 15 Because Law is working down settled anger’, (Romans 4 v 14, 15a). These two means of judicial approval are in many ways mutually exclusive. When it comes to divine law, the written codes are bringing down settled anger, whereas the arrangement of judicial approval by means of faith exists beside Covenant Law, in the sense that it does not abolish or dissolve divine Law, but brings it to completion and with it, divine judicial approval.

Principles of living a set apart, godly life [28] – Divine Law, Priesthood and the Millennium Reign [4]

 There is only one formal order of priests on earth and they are selected from the tribe of Levi within God’s chosen ethnic group – the house of Israel. This is quite consistent with what Ezekiel describes in the last chapters of his book. His description of the use of daily sacrifices demonstrates that Jews will not, as a nation, suddenly convert to Christianity in the sense of dismissing ceremonies and sacrifices. Rather, they will remain under a form of a neo-Levitical priestly order under the New Covenant that God will make with the house of Israel. Within the heavenly realm, the priesthood is being transferred from out of necessity, from out of compelling need, and a transfer of law is coming into being, (Hebrews 7 v 12). As a result, under the New Covenant, the house of Israel will be softened and made responsive to God’s Law, which He will write on their deep inner core. They will become a set-apart godly nation. They will begin to turn back to God and His Messiah, as King of kings, will overthrow of the tyranny of the ‘man of lawlessness’ and his regime with the furious outpouring of passionate anger. This will occur in the last generation of this present gospel age.   

By this time, all those brought forth by God will be roused up again to enter into the heavenly realm. What will be established will be the ‘New Jerusalem’ – the new infrastructure of delegated governance, of delegated rulers, judges and authorities, made up in part of a Kingdom of priests resembling the order of Melchizedek, serving in the heavenly temple. In addition, heaven and earth will draw closer together, with human delegated rulers and judges in Israel, its priests of a neo-Levitical order. This whole new order, including God as the Ultimate Authority and Jesus as King of kings seems to be what is referred to as ‘Zion’, with completed Christians constituting part of the ‘New Jerusalem’. Thus we read, ‘I clearly discerned the city set apart, the fresh, new, unused Jerusalem, coming down from out of heaven away from God, made ready in the manner of a bride very appealingly ordered and adorned for her husband. And I heard a loud voice from out of the throne saying, “Look! The dwelling place of God in company with men - He will be encamping in company with them and they will be His peoples. God Himself, their God, will be in company with them’, (Revelation 21 v 2, 3).

The important thing for us to note in all of this, before we get too distracted by other themes and details, is that all of this is established in company with, in parallel with divine Law. As Jesus said in the gospels, he had not come to abolish divine Law but to complete it. Divine law is not going to be abolished or dissolved, but it is going to be transferred. It constitutes the foundation of God’s justice and righteousness and at no point will God introduce an arrangement of lawlessness, anarchy or permissiveness. 

I have taken a little time to establish this context so that we can better understand what the Apostle Paul has to say about the day-by-day life of Christians and the written codes of Sinai Covenant Law. It also helps us to avoid falling into the trap of excessive freedom or permissiveness. I am certainly not taking an ‘antinomian’ stance – a perspective that stands opposed to, or against, divine law. But neither am I supporting Christian legalism.